Kiss Meets the Phantom of the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame
Jan 26, 2010 by Aaron
Every year I wait, and every year I’m disappointed. And like all things in this country I believe it boils down to politics and insider connections. It is no different that an exclusive Georgian golf county club or a skull and bones type secret society…
To my colleague, Nick at Rock Minutes, you had to know this article was coming. My love of the band Kiss has never been kept under a bush, oh no. Kiss’ multi-platinum album Destroyer, was the first album I ever owned, my parents purchased it for me when I was seven. The purchase of Destroyer was followed closely by Rock and Roll Over, and Love Gun. Then the next albums my parents purchased for me were the Solo Faces side project. I was about 10 by then, and I owned seven albums and they were all Kiss albums. I would play them on an old turn table that had one small speaker cut in its base about the size of a beverage coaster; and it sounded good to me. Kiss was my world. I had three Kiss t-shirts, ringers of course and a Kiss lunch box. I also had about 37 Kiss posters that covered three of my four bedroom walls. Oh, did I mention I had all the original Kiss dolls too; and you could place them in any crazy pose. The commercial did not lie! Kiss has been influential in my life, there is no doubt. And in fact, they have influenced pop culture in general as much as any band in the history of Rock and Roll, so tell me, “Why is KISS still not in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?”
Really, what did I know about music pre-pubescent? Truthfully, I didn’t know much. But I knew I loved Kiss and everything about them. I loved the larger than life image. I loved their honest sound of “boot to the face” straight-forward rock and roll. I loved the mystery and allure of the grease paint and perceived mystical magic.
My love for this band has never wavered. Some may agree that this love stems from nostalgia and not musicianship; nevertheless they are still my favorite band, and that is a fight I am not afraid to take on.
One thing that has always upset me about the critics is how they have always been over looked sonically and artistically. Many critics think the band is just about marketing and money and not about the music, but without the music there would have been no market. Think about it logically, would Star Wars merchandise have sold like it did if the movie was never made? Of course not, it was the enduring image and feeling of the movie that made the marketing so successful. Kiss is the same. Their music was rock solid. And, their music holds up better than most bands from their era still today. I believe that many of their songs could be re-recorded by any modern band and be hits today. Many of their tunes still sound fresh and relevant.
Their critics say they are not good musicians and their lyrics lack sophistication. That is such a surface argument, and an argument made by people who have never delved deep into Kiss’ reservoir of music. Songs like Watchin You, Goin Blind, Parasite, and Black Diamond are great examples of songs that are both sonically stellar and lyrically strong. Of course there were a lot of songs about girls and sex too. And because of this some critics would like to call their music simplistic, but this is rock and roll for God’s sake, it’s a genre about love, rebellion, heartache, sex, and bravado. Without those aforementioned things, Glenn Miller would still be on the pop charts. For the everyday critic to disregard their music and lyrics without getting deep into their musical reservoir is sophomoric at best.
Ace is a fantastic guitar player and Paul is a stellar rhythm guitarist, and quite possibly one of the greatest front men in Rock History. He was in a league with the likes of Robert Plant, Rodger Daltry, and Freddie Mercury. Gene is a suitable bass player and Peter’s make up was pretty cool (Sorry Pete, but you were the weak link sonically). Although Eric Carr who replaced Peter Criss was a monster on the drums and there is no way to say otherwise.
Kiss were trailblazers. There was not a true hard “American” Rock band before Kiss, with the exception of Aerosmith, who revolutionized and created that “American” hard rock sound and movement of the 70’s and 80’s. Think about it, most hard rock bands were coming from England (i.e. Led Zeppelin, The Who, and Black Sabbath). Kiss was one of the first hard rock bands from America. They created a whole genre of music – the glam rock movement. They were the Nirvana of their period. It could be argued that Kiss’ music influences everything from Hair Metal to Grunge, to Alt Rock to Indie.
Kiss has had 13 Top 40 hits, released 30 albums, and sold over 100 albums million worldwide. Twenty-nine of their 30 albums have been certified gold and 19 of them, platinum. So tell me, why they have been left out of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame again! Let me tell you, that dog don’t hunt.
Kiss being left out of the RRHF once again does not discredit them, moreover it discredits the institution its self. If the RRHF cannot see the accomplishments of one the most important and influential band of all time, than I have to question its legitimacy. There is little doubt they should be in, actually, there’s no doubt at all.
Posted in Aaron's Musings from the Outhouse
















Great article! I’ve always considered Kiss the Michael Bay of music. They create music for a specific crowd and they do good job at that. Doesn’t mean I think Michael Bay deserves an Oscar though; however, I do agree that Kiss deserves to be in the RRHF.
KISS VS R&RHOF (Rock & Roll Hall of Fame…..or ….Shame?)
{I wrote this several weeks ago after going to see KISS the second time this year in Pittsburgh and they were rejected by the R&RHOF. After seeing the Rolling Stone Poll in their 2/4 issue (57% voted that KISS should be in the R&RHOF) I had to send this letter to Rolling Stone, first time I have ever sent a letter to any magazine.}
In Rocktober I was fortunate to be able to see AC/DC in Wash, DC on 10/16, KISS in Greenville, SC on 10/17, and Metallica in Charlotte, NC on 10/18. (I live in VA, grew up in SC; and I’m lucky to have an understanding R&R wife and still have a great old friend from High School.) All three concerts were great and it was an awesome three days and nights! But the KISS show emotionally, sonically, and theatrically blew the other two away (and I’m a big AC/DC & Metallica fan). I saw KISS for the first time in 1976 in Greenville (yes, I’m 50 years old…). It had been five years since I’ve seen KISS, and they were amazing. Playing the original music from KISS Alive! made it even more emotional for us. It’s just an incredible show! Everyone was screaming, smiling, standing, dancing, and playing air guitar throughout the entire show!
My friend and I were so impressed that we travelled to Cleveland the weekend of 12/12 to tour the R&RHOF, and then drove to Pittsburgh to see KISS on 12/13. We thought KISS would certainly get voted in since they were Finally nominated (the reason we tied the trip together). It appears we were taken. The $22 admission for the R&RHOF was waaay too much and the $130 for KISS was a bargain! My friend and I had debated (and both with our wives of course), if going to see KISS the second time in two months and spending the $ for the concert and the hotels in Cleveland and Pittsburgh made any sense? But in all honesty, the millisecond that the KISS curtain started to drop, the flames hit the ceiling, and the first chords of Deuce hit us in the chest…..we both knew it was completely worth it and wished we had spent more $ to get even closer to the stage!
I understand the KISS detractors out there that may say that KISS is not the BEST Band in the world and they are not the BEST Musicians, but have they ever seen KISS in concert? Paul orchestrates the concert and converses with the crowd pulling them into the show, and he Truly seems to enjoy it! You have to be there to See it, Feel it, and Be Part of it! I KNOW the voters for the R&RHOF haven’t! If they had, they would know that KISS live in concert is what Rock and Roll was meant to be all about!!
So debate all you want – KISS brings Emotion, Energy, Escape, Sex, and Sheer Joy to their show! For two hours you escape from the real world, your worries, back to that feeling we / you had when we were ~21 years old on a SATURDAY Night…….that…. ”let’s Rock!,…have a few drinks,…meet some girls,…and get laid!”….that feeling…..is BACK!! And until they invent the Pill that takes you back to that experience, for me the best way to get back (without getting divorced) is KISS ALIVE!!! So what’s next….now that the US Tour is over?….Well….. I’m wishfully checking airfares to Stockholm…..on (YES!) SATURDAY Night, June 12th……but I haven’t told my wife yet……
R&RHOF: This private club is obviously maintained by arrogant political appointees. It’s not about popular votes or fairness and good judgment. Due to the goodness of the hearts of the masses it has been accepted since it is one of the only “shrines” to a generation of rock & rollers. Yet the needs of the masses are not being met by this club. Unfortunately, I can understand ABBA getting in since (per most websites) they are only behind The Beatles, Elvis, and M. Jackson for total worldwide albums sold (hard to believe huh!?). But Give Us A Break “The Hollies”? over KISS? Unbelievable!!!
AHH….BUT…DON’T WORRY…..it’s all good….just give Gene a few more years and he’ll buy the R&RHOF!!! And when this happens….. and he has flames eternally shooting out of the roof, and blood dripping down the stairs, I’ll go back…..but not until then!
JTMy